| UFC Fight Night | 03/24 03:55 | - | Karl Williams v Justin Tafa | 1-0 | |
| UFC | 02/18 01:20 | - | Marcos Rogerio de Lima v Justin Tafa | CANC | |
| UFC | 09/10 02:35 | - | Justin Tafa v Austen Lane | 1-0 | |
| UFC Fight Night | 06/24 20:20 | - | Austen Lane v Justin Tafa | CANC | |
| UFC | 02/12 04:00 | - | Justin Tafa v Parker Porter | View | |
| UFC | 02/12 03:55 | - | Justin Tafa v Parker Porter | 1-0 | |
| UFC Fight Night | 12/18 23:10 | - | Justin Tafa v Harry Hunsucker | 1-0 | |
| UFC Fight Night | 05/23 00:40 | - | Justin Tafa v Jared Vanderaa | 0-1 | |
| UFC Fight Night | 01/16 19:05 | - | Justin Tafa v Carlos Felipe | 0-1 | |
| UFC | 02/09 04:30 | - | Juan Adams v Justin Tafa | 0-1 | |
| UFC | 10/06 02:00 | - | Justin Tafa v Yorgan De Castro | 0-1 |